When you book a holiday, you’ll need to make one fundamental decision before anything else: do you book a package holiday where everything’s bundled together, or do you DIY it and piece together flights, accommodation, and activities yourself?
Both approaches have their champions. Package holiday fans love the simplicity and peace of mind. DIY planners enjoy the flexibility and potential savings. Neither is objectively better – they suit different types of travellers, different destinations, and different circumstances.
The choice affects not just your budget but your entire holiday experience. Get it right and you’ll have a brilliant trip that matches your needs perfectly. Get it wrong and you’ll either be frustrated by restrictions or stressed by logistics you weren’t prepared to handle.
Let’s break down the real pros and cons of each approach so you can figure out which works for your next break.
What Actually Is a Package Holiday?
Package holidays bundle at least two elements – typically flights and accommodation, often with transfers and sometimes meals or activities included. You book everything through one company in a single transaction, and they handle the logistics.
ATOL protection (in the UK) covers package holidays, meaning you’re financially protected if the company goes bust or things go wrong. This legal protection doesn’t apply to separate bookings, which is a significant difference.
Packages range from basic flight-plus-hotel deals to fully inclusive resort experiences where meals, drinks, and activities are all covered. The level of bundling varies massively depending on what you choose.
Package Holiday Pros
The simplicity is genuinely brilliant. One booking, one confirmation, one point of contact if something goes wrong. You’re not juggling multiple reservations or coordinating various companies. Everything’s sorted in one transaction.
Financial protection through ATOL gives proper peace of mind. If your tour operator goes bust, you’re protected and won’t lose your money. Book flights and hotels separately and you’re on your own if one provider fails.
Packages often work out cheaper than booking everything separately, particularly for popular beach destinations. Tour operators negotiate bulk rates with hotels and airlines that individuals can’t access. The savings can be substantial, especially during school holidays when independent bookings get extortionate.
Transfer logistics are handled for you. No figuring out how to get from the airport to your hotel at midnight in a foreign country – someone’s meeting you and taking you there. This is massive when you’re tired, dealing with kids, or arriving somewhere you don’t speak the language.
Packages are brilliant for stress-free holidays where you genuinely want to switch off. Everything’s pre-arranged, you’re not making decisions constantly, and you can just relax.
Package Holiday Cons
Flexibility is the massive trade-off. You’re locked into specific flights, specific hotels, specific dates. Want to extend your trip by a few days? Not possible. Want to change hotels halfway through? Tough luck. The rigidity that makes packages simple also makes them inflexible.
You’re stuck with what’s offered. Don’t like the hotel they’ve paired with your flight? You can pick a different package, but you can’t mix and match elements from various packages to create exactly what you want.
Hidden costs can add up. That cheap package price might not include baggage, seat selection, airport transfers in some cases, or meals beyond breakfast. By the time you’ve added everything you actually need, the headline price has increased significantly.
Quality can be questionable. Some package operators cut costs by using budget hotels in less desirable locations or scheduling flights at horrible times. The cheapest package often means the worst hotel and a 3am flight home.
You’re dealing with other package tourists constantly. If you want to avoid the British abroad experience – crowded pools, full English breakfasts, and everyone speaking English – packages often concentrate you with exactly that crowd.
Package holidays work brilliantly for certain destinations and situations but can feel restrictive if you want spontaneity or have specific preferences the package can’t accommodate.
DIY Planning Pros
Complete control over every element is the major advantage. You pick exactly the flights you want, exactly the accommodation you prefer, exactly the activities you’re interested in. Want to stay in a quirky boutique hotel rather than a chain? Easily done. Prefer an early flight rather than a late one? Book it.
Flexibility to change plans is enormous. Fancy staying an extra night somewhere? Book another night. Want to move hotels halfway through? Rearrange your bookings. You’re not locked into predetermined schedules.
You can save serious money if you’re smart about it. Budget airlines, last-minute hotel deals, alternative accommodation like holiday cottages – you’ve got options that might cost way less than packages. Particularly if you’re flexible with dates or willing to stay slightly outside tourist centres.
Off-the-beaten-path destinations work better with DIY planning. Packages tend to cover mainstream tourist spots. If you want to explore somewhere less conventional, you’ll probably need to plan it yourself anyway.
You avoid the package tourism scene entirely. Stay where locals stay, eat where locals eat, have experiences that aren’t standardised for tourists. For some people, this is the whole point of travel.
DIY planning lets you create exactly the holiday you want rather than the holiday tour operators think you should have.
DIY Planning Cons
The time investment is significant. You’re researching flights, comparing hotels, figuring out transfers, planning activities, coordinating timings. This can take hours or even days depending on trip complexity. Some people enjoy this process; others find it tedious.
There’s no financial protection equivalent to ATOL. If your separately-booked flight gets cancelled or your hotel goes bust, you’re chasing refunds yourself. Travel insurance helps but doesn’t provide the same blanket protection as package holidays.
You’re the problem-solver when things go wrong. Missed connection? Your problem. Hotel overbooked? You’re sorting it. Package holidays have reps and customer service handling issues. DIY means you’re the customer service.
It can actually cost more if you’re not strategic. Peak-time flights, last-minute hotel bookings, tourist-area accommodation – these can add up to more than a package would’ve cost. The potential to save exists, but you need to be smart about how you book.
Coordinating logistics gets complicated. Making sure your arrival flight lands with enough time to collect bags, clear customs, and catch your connection. Ensuring your accommodation is actually near what you want to see. All this requires planning and research.
When Packages Make Most Sense
Beach holidays where you’re staying in one resort for a week work brilliantly as packages. You’re not moving around, you want simplicity, and package deals to Mediterranean or Caribbean resorts often offer excellent value.
Family holidays during school holidays benefit from packages. When everyone’s booking the same weeks, tour operators’ bulk-buying power saves you money compared to booking independently when prices spike.
First-time international travellers or people uncomfortable navigating foreign countries appreciate the hand-holding and support packages provide. Everything’s arranged, you’ve got reps to ask questions, and you’re not figuring everything out alone.
Short breaks where you want maximum relaxation with minimum planning suit packages. You’ve only got a few days – spending half of one researching and booking isn’t appealing.
When DIY Makes Most Sense
Multi-destination trips where you’re moving around need DIY planning. Packages don’t typically cover complex itineraries with multiple stops, and even when they do, they’re more expensive than booking independently.
Long trips where you want flexibility benefit from DIY. Booking return flights and everything in between yourself lets you adjust plans as you travel rather than being locked into predetermined schedules.
Niche interests or specific requirements work better with DIY. Cycling holidays, food tours, adventure travel – these often require specific accommodation or timing that packages can’t accommodate. Budget travel where you’re using hostels, budget airlines, or alternative accommodation doesn’t suit package formats. You’ll save money booking independently using budget options.
And if you fancy browsing holiday homes in the countryside, we at Downwood Holidays have endless packages on offer for all the family.
The Hybrid Approach
You’re not actually limited to pure packages or pure DIY. Many people combine elements – book flights independently but use package transfers and accommodation, or book a package for the main destination but add DIY extensions before or after.
Dynamic packaging tools let you create semi-customised packages, choosing specific flights and hotels but still getting ATOL protection. This middle ground offers some flexibility whilst maintaining financial protection.
The Bottom Line
Package holidays offer simplicity, financial protection, and often good value for mainstream destinations and standard itineraries. They work brilliantly when you want stress-free holidays with everything pre-arranged.
DIY planning provides complete control, flexibility, and potential cost savings but requires time investment and leaves you responsible for logistics and problem-solving. It suits travellers who want specific experiences or enjoy the planning process.
Neither is universally better – choose based on your destination, how much time you have for planning, your comfort level with independent travel, your budget and whether packages or DIY offers better value, and whether you prioritise flexibility or simplicity. The best choice is the one that matches your travel style, destination, and priorities for this specific trip.
Our Fact Checking Process
We prioritize accuracy and integrity in our content. Here's how we maintain high standards:
- Expert Review: All articles are reviewed by subject matter experts.
- Source Validation: Information is backed by credible, up-to-date sources.
- Transparency: We clearly cite references and disclose potential conflicts.
Your trust is important. Learn more about our Fact Checking process and editorial policy.
Our Review Board
Our content is carefully reviewed by experienced professionals to ensure accuracy and relevance.
- Qualified Experts: Each article is assessed by specialists with field-specific knowledge.
- Up-to-date Insights: We incorporate the latest research, trends, and standards.
- Commitment to Quality: Reviewers ensure clarity, correctness, and completeness.
Look for the expert-reviewed label to read content you can trust.
